Not A Second Time

Song facts

From Wikipedia:

“Not a Second Time” is a song by John Lennon (credited to Lennon–McCartney) performed by the Beatles on their second United Kingdom album, With the Beatles. Lennon said he was “trying to write a Smokey Robinson or something at the time.”

Musical structure

This song inspired a musical analysis from William Mann of The Times, citing the “Aeolian cadence” (Aeolian harmony) of Lennon’s vocals as the song draws to a close, and noting that the same chord progression appears at the end of the final movement of Mahler’s “Das Lied von der Erde.” Lennon, years later, remarked: “To this day, I have no idea what [Aeolian cadences] are. They sound like exotic birds.” The actual meaning of the term “Aeolian cadence” is when a major key song resolves on the vi chord, which is the tonic chord of the relative minor key. The term derives from the fact that the Aeolian mode is rooted on the sixth step of the major scale.

Dominic Pedler considers the “Aeolian cadence” moment to occur at the end of this line: (Am) “You hurt me then. You’re back again. No/(Bm) no no/(D7) not a second time“/(Em). Pedler writes: “We are expecting the D7 chord, the dominant in the key of G, to return to the G major tonic“. However, in replacing it with an Em chord supporting an isolated E note on “time“, we have an interrupted cadence or dominant-to-relative sub-minor (V7 to vi) shift. The major key of the song is G, but it appears to resolve on the Em (vi) chord. As Allan Moore puts it, “Mann would argue that it is not the same thing as a ‘V-vi’ Interrupted or Deceptive cadence because — at that precise point in the song — the role of the E minor as a ‘vi’ is being questioned and is veering towards tonic status.”

Pedler notes that another interesting moment in the song is that George Martin’s piano part alternates not between G and E minor, but G and E major, the presence of the piano’s extra G# (the major 3rd of the E chord) creating a “grating, tense colouring” in comparison to a G natural of the guitar’s Em chord. Pedler’s discussion with musical experts about the comparison between this Beatles song and Mahler’s “Song of the Earth” revealed that none found anything relevant, except perhaps that Mahler’s Farewell movement involves various shades of a C major chord and ends after a flute B-A drop (the A chord being a VI in the chord of C) with the “final sonority” of a C6 (where the C, E and G notes are from the trombones and lower strings and the A from oboe and flute) (this final C6 chord seeming to be “printed on the atmosphere“, as Benjamin Britten terms it).

Recording

The song was recorded in nine takes on 11 September 1963 at EMI Studios.

This was the first Beatles recording not to feature George Harrison.

From The Usenet Guide to Beatles Recording Variations:

• [a] mono 30 Sep 1963.
  UK: Parlophone PMC 1206 With the Beatles 1963.
  CD: EMI CDP 7 46436 2 With the Beatles 1987.
• [b] stereo 29 Oct 1963.
  UK: Parlophone PCS 3045 With the Beatles 1963.
• [b1] stereo remixed from [b] 1963, by Capitol.
  US: Capitol ST 2047 Meet the Beatles 1964.
• [b2] mono made from [b] 1963, by Capitol.
  US: Capitol T 2047 Meet the Beatles 1964.

Last updated on February 8, 2016

Lyrics