Album This song officially appears on the Memory Almost Full Official album.
Timeline This song was officially released in 2007
This song was recorded during the following studio sessions:
"Memory Almost Full" first sessions
End of February 2004
David Kahne talks about Memory Almost Full
Jun 01, 2007
Interview with The Onion/A.V. Club
Jun 27, 2007 • From The Onion/A.V. Club
“You Tell Me” is a song from Paul McCartney’s 2007 album, “Memory Almost Full“.
I started off just remembering summers: ‘Were we really there?’ ‘Was it real?’ Sometimes, for a lot of people, memories – particularly childhood memories – seem so golden and you think, ‘Did it really not rain all summer or am I just imagining the sunny bits?’ And then the phrase ‘You tell me’ began to be the theme of the song. I wrote it out in Long Island, during one of those summers. I was looking at a red cardinal – and for someone English that is kind of magical, seeing a bright red bird coming out of a tree – so he appeared in the lyric. A lot of what’s in the lyric was there as I was writing. It became a tribute to golden summers.
Paul McCartney – interview with Mail On Sunday, May 12, 2008
Interview with David Khane, from Mix Online, October 1, 2007:
“‘You Tell Me’ is maybe the saddest song he’s ever written,” Kahne says. McCartney wrote the song in Long Island, and is, as he describes, “a tribute to golden summers.” The mostly acoustic number opens with some forward and backward organ, along with Laboriel playing a drum pad triggering some drum samples. McCartney’s vocal was recorded in a single pass, joined by beautiful vocals from the bandmembers. The backward/forward organ, used to create a mood, is followed by a quiet count-in from McCartney. “I was really happy he let me include the count-in. It’s iconic.”
When was that summer when the skies were blue?
The bright red cardinal flew down from
his tree
You tell me
When was that summer when it never rained?
The air was buzzin' with the sweet old honey bee
Let's see
You tell me
Were we there, was it real?
Is it truly how I feel?
Maybe
You tell me
Were we there, is it true?
Was I really there with you?
Let's see
You tell me
When was that summer of a dozen words?
The butterflies and hummingbirds flew free
Let's see
You tell me
Let's see
You tell me
Memory Almost Full - 2CD limited edition bonus disc
Official album • Released in 2007
3:16 • Studio version • A
Official album • Released in 2007
3:16 • Studio version • A
Paul McCartney : Acoustic guitar, Bass, Vocals Rusty Anderson : Backing vocals, Electric guitar Abe Laboriel Jr. : Backing vocals, Drums David Kahne : Mixing engineer, Producer Paul Wickens : Backing vocals, Electric piano Brian Ray : Backing vocals Andy Wallace : Mixing engineer
Session Recording: End of February 2004 • Studio EMI Studios, Abbey Road
Credits & recording details courtesy of Luca Perasi • Buy Paul McCartney: Music Is Ideas. The Stories Behind the Songs (Vol. 1) 1970-1989 on Amazon
Memory Almost Full - Ultimate Archive Collection
Unofficial album • Released in 2016
3:14 • Studio version • A
Paul McCartney has never played this song in concert.
The Lyrics: 1956 to the Present
"You Tell Me" is one of the songs featured in the book "The Lyrics: 1956 to the Present," published in 2021. The book explores Paul McCartney's early Liverpool days, his time with the Beatles, Wings, and his solo career. It pairs the lyrics of 154 of his songs with his first-person commentary on the circumstances of their creation, the inspirations behind them, and his current thoughts on them.
Notice any inaccuracies on this page? Have additional insights or ideas for new content? Or just want to share your thoughts? We value your feedback! Please use the form below to get in touch with us.
Steve • 1 year ago
No matter what, this song is about dementia. It is such a sad song. Like the title of this masterpiece album, it beautifully and compassionately describes what a dementia person goes through. “Was I there, was it real?” are sentiments I’m asked of my poor mother. As a caregiver, this song gives me much comfort. It is perfect. It is my go-to “in times of trouble”.
