- Album This song officially appears on the Beatles For Sale (Mono) LP.
Related sessions
This song has been recorded during the following studio sessions
Sep 29, 1964
Sep 30, 1964
"Beatles for Sale" Session #10
Oct 26, 1964
"Beatles for Sale" Session #11
Oct 27, 1964
Spread the love! If you like what you are seeing, share it on social networks and let others know about The Paul McCartney Project.
Song facts
From Wikipedia:
“What You’re Doing” is a song by the Beatles written by Paul McCartney (credited to Lennon–McCartney). One of eight originals of fourteen songs on the 1964 album Beatles for Sale, it also appeared on the 1965 U.S album Beatles VI.
Music
The song begins, uncommonly for the band, with a drum intro. It is followed by a guitar sequence used throughout the song as an ostinato figure after each verse. The atmosphere of the song is heavily syncopated.
According to Richie Unterberger, the performance includes a “chiming 12-string guitar that sounds uncannily like the kind of sounds that became identified with the Byrds’ Roger McGuinn, although ‘What You’re Doing’ was recorded in late 1964, about six months before the Byrds became famous with ‘Mr. Tambourine Man.’“
The song lacks a chorus, so the verses become the melodic focus of the song. In the first half of the verse, the ostinato figure continues to play and the first word of each line is punctuated by exclamatory background vocals. The second half of each verse is harmonized with “oohs“, and the ostinato figure begins before the last line finishes. The overlapping of the ostinato figure contributes to the slightly disordered feel of the song. Each verse ends with a repetition of the phrase:
There is a bridge that occurs twice to provide a reprieve from the more anxious verses and an instrumental breakdown with a double-tracked guitar solo and a tumbling piano keeping rhythm underneath.
Lyrics
The lyrics are generally believed to concern McCartney’s relationship with Jane Asher. Between McCartney and Lennon, McCartney had typically been the more optimistic of the two when it came to songwriting. However, with this song he is expressing feelings of loneliness and doubt in his relationship, a theme he would be forced to develop more over time as his relationship soured, with songs like I’m Looking Through You and You Won’t See Me from Rubber Soul, and For No One from Revolver.
Throughout the song, McCartney adds to the rhyme scheme by combining a single, two-syllable word with two one-syllable words (i.e. “Look what you’re doing, I’m feeling blue and lonely…You got me runnin’, and there’s no fun in it…“), a technique he also used on She’s a Woman which was also recorded during the Beatles For Sale sessions. […]
Sampling
This song is sampled as part of a medley of “Drive My Car” / “The Word” / “What You’re Doing” on the November 2006 remix album Love. “What You’re Doing” shares a number of characteristics with (the also predominantly McCartney-written) “Drive My Car”, particularly the home key (D major), meter (4/4), and chord progression (alternating between B minor and G major).
Paul McCartney, in Many Years From Now, by Barry Miles:
What You’re Doing was a bit of a filler. I think it was a little more mine than John’s, but I don’t have a very clear recollection so to be on the safe side I’d put it as 50-50. It doesn’t sound like an idea that I remember John offering, so it sounds like a way to get a song started, some of them are just that. ‘Hey, what’cha doing?’ You sometimes start a song and hope the best bit will arrive by the time you get to the chorus… but sometimes that’s all you get, and I suspect this was one of them. Maybe it’s a better recording than it is a song, some of them are. Sometimes a good recording would enhance the song.
From The Usenet Guide to Beatles Recording Variations:
- [a] mono [27 Oct 1964 – Edit]
UK: Parlophone PMC 1240 For Sale 1964.
US: Capitol T 2358 Beatles VI 1965.
CD: EMI CDP 7 46438 2 For Sale 1987.- [b] stereo [27 Oct 1964 – Edit]
UK: Parlophone PCS 3062 For Sale 1964.
US: Capitol ST 2358 Beatles VI 1965.[b] has a handclap in the intro missing in [a], and the drum and rhythm track is mixed softer.
Another one Paul wrote on tour in Philadelphia or somewhere.
John Lennon – Interview with Ray Connolly, 1970 – From “The Ray Connolly Beatles Archive”
Last updated on January 26, 2022
Lyrics
Look what you're doing
I'm feeling blue and lonely
Would it be too much to ask of you
What you're doing to me?
You got me running
And there's no fun in it
Why should it be so much to ask of you
What you're doing to me?
I've been waiting here for you
Wondering what you're gonna do
And should you need a love that's true
It's me
Please, stop your lying
You've got me crying, girl
Why should it be so much to ask of you
What you're doing to me?
I've been waiting here for you
Wondering what you're gonna do
And should you need a love that's true
It's me
Please, stop your lying
You've got me crying, girl
Why should it be so much to ask of you
What you're doing to me?
What you're doing to me
What you're doing to me
Officially appears on
LP • Released in 1964
2:30 • Studio version • A • Mono
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
LP • Released in 1964
2:30 • Studio version • B • Stereo
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 1965
2:30 • Studio version • A • Mono
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 1965
2:30 • Studio version • B • Stereo
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2006
0:00 • Studio version • C • As reported, the medley features the guitar solo from "Taxman" and the horns section from "Savoy Truffle".
- George Martin :
- Producer
- Giles Martin :
- Producer
- Paul Hicks :
- Remix engineer
- Sam Okell :
- Remix engineer assistant
- Chris Bolster :
- Remix engineer assistant
- Mirek Stiles :
- Remix engineer assistant
- Session Mixing:
- Circa 2004-2006
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2006
2:30 • Studio version • B2006 • Stereo • 2006 remaster
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Ted Jensen :
- Remastering
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Official album • Released in 2006
2:30 • Studio version • A2006 • Mono • 2006 remaster
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Ted Jensen :
- Remastering
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles for Sale (Mono - 2009 remaster)
Official album • Released in 2009
2:30 • Studio version • A2009 • Mono • 2009 mono remaster
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Paul Hicks :
- Remastering
- Guy Massey :
- Remastering
- Sean Magee :
- Remastering
- Allan Rouse :
- Project co-ordinator
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles for Sale (Stereo - 2009 remaster)
Official album • Released in 2009
2:30 • Studio version • B2009 • Stereo • 2009 stereo remaster
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Guy Massey :
- Remastering
- Steve Rooke :
- Remastering
- Allan Rouse :
- Project co-ordinator
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale (Mono - 2014 vinyl)
LP • Released in 2014
2:30 • Studio version • A2014 • Mono • 2014 remaster
- Paul McCartney :
- Bass, Vocals
- Ringo Starr :
- Drums
- John Lennon :
- Acoustic rhythm guitar, Harmony vocals
- George Harrison :
- Harmony vocals, Lead guitar
- George Martin :
- Piano, Producer
- Norman Smith :
- Recording engineer
- Sean Magee :
- Remastering
- Steve Berkowitz :
- Remastering
- Session Recording:
- Sep 29, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Recording:
- Oct 26, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
- Session Mixing:
- Oct 27, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Bootlegs
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
2:13 • Alternate take • Stereo • Take 11
- Session Recording:
- Sep 30, 1964
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
0:21 • Alternate take • unknown Take Stereo
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Beatles For Sale - Studio Sessions - Back To Basics
Unofficial album • Released in 2011
0:21 • Alternate take • unknown Take - clean VHS mix Mono
- Studio :
- EMI Studios, Studio Two, Abbey Road
Live performances
Paul McCartney has never played this song in concert.
Contribute!
Have you spotted an error on the page? Do you want to suggest new content? Or do you simply want to leave a comment ? Please use the form below!